Federalismo fiscale comp

4b/2017: Fiscal Federalism and responsibility from a comparative perspective: translating a financial principle into practice through legal instruments (PhD-project)

  • Deutsch
  • English
  • Italiano
  • Project duration: December 2011 - October 2018
  • Project status: finished
  • Funding:
    Internal funding EURAC (Project)

The PhD project investigates the principle of financial responsibility from a comparative and legal perspective. Case studies are Germany (i.e. the Länder) and Spain (i.e. the Autonomous Communities of common regime).

From a political point of view, financial responsibility is a fundamental component of any decentralizing process. From an economic perspective, it is a precondition for efficiency. Therefore, financial responsibility becomes the cornerstone of all compound States. At the same time, the “welfare state” model calls for a system in which autonomy and solidarity shall coexist.

Against this background, second-generation theories of fiscal federalism underpin the concept of “fiscal responsibility at the margin” and advocate for, at least, partial responsibility of subnational entities on the revenue side. The idea builds on the argument that entities entrusted with own financing powers tend to be politically more responsible to their citizens. This is due to the assumption that financial responsibility through democratic control serves as a tool to strengthen political autonomy itself.

The theoretical construct is well reflected in the selected case-studies, as it has been the trajectory for the Spanish reform in 2009, as well as for the reform under discussion in Germany.

Moving from the theoretical paradigm of “fiscal responsibility at the margin” to legal practice, the need to observe how and to what extent revenue is distributed among and within the different layers of governments emerges. The major issue at stake is the revenue structure of the intermediate tier of government, paying particular attention to the legal tools and procedures devoted to revenue-sharing, as all these elements play a great role in defining the extent of financial autonomy on the revenue side.

After some preliminary remarks on the background theories governing the scenario and on the essential features of the selected case-studies, the investigation focuses on the principle of financial responsibility as embedded in the legal frameworks and developed through constitutional jurisprudence. Then, it scrutinizes, classifies and compares the legal tools, which put the principle into practice. The ultimate aim is to provide a comparative measurement and assessment of these instruments, in order to estimate the existing margin of responsibility vested in the intermediate level of government, that is, the autonomous Communities and the Länder. In doing so, the system of intergovernmental financial relations will be taken into consideration paying attention to both the “law in books” and the “law in action”. This approach is pivotal for understanding the way in which these systems function.

A paper on the PhD topic (with the title "Financial constitutions and responsibility at the margin: from legal framework to practice") has been awarded the IFÖ Preis 2016 for studies on federalism and regionalism (IFÖ Innsbruck and Konferenz der österreichischen Landtagspräsidenten). Another paper on a related topic (with the title Financial constitutions and responsibility at the margin: from legal framework to practice) has been awarded on November 2016 in Delhi the Ronald Watts Young Researcher Award 2016, from the International Association of Centres for Federal Studies (IACFS).

A volume with the title "Federalismo fiscale e responsabilizzazione politico-finanziaria. Comparazione giuridica ed esercizi di misurazione del diritto" will be published in Italian language, presenting the main results of the study.

The project will expire at the end of 2017.

Book presentation ‘Alice Valdesalici, Federalismo fiscale e responsabilizzazione politico finanziaria. Comparazione giuridica ed esercizi di misurazione del diritto, Edizioni Scientifiche Italiane, 2018’
Valdesalici A (2021)

Conference: STALS (Sant'Anna Legal Studies) seminars (online event) | Pisa (online event) | 24.3.2021 - 24.3.2021


Quando la forma incide sulla sostanza: le fonti (e le sorti) del federalismo fiscale in Italia
Parolari S (2020)
Contribution in book
Costituzioni finanziarie e riforme: Italia e Spagna a confronto

More information: http://www.eurac.edu/en/research/Publications/Pages/publicat ...


From a formal to a substantial approach: sources of law and fiscal federalism
Parolari S (2018)
Contribution in book
Comparing Fiscal Federalism


Our partners

Generalität de Catalunya, Instituts d'Estudis Autonòmics

Project Team
1 - 2


1 - 10

Winter School

6a/2022: Winter School on Federalism and Governance

Duration: December 2008 - May 2022Funding: Public institutions (Other projects ...

view all

Institute's Projects

Eurac Research logo

Eurac Research is a private research center based in Bolzano (South Tyrol) with researchers from a wide variety of scientific fields who come from all over the globe. Together, through scientific knowledge and research, they share the goal of shaping the future.

What we do

Our research addresses the greatest challenges facing us in the future: people need health, energy, well-functioning political and social systems and an intact environment. These are complex questions, and we are seeking the answers in the interaction between many different disciplines. In so doing, our research work embraces three major themes: regions fit for living in, diversity as a life-enhancing feature, a healthy society.

Great Place To Work
ISO 9001 / 2015ISO 9001:2015
ISO 27001ISO 27001:2013
ORCID Member

Except where otherwise noted, content on this site is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International license.

In order to give you a better service this site uses cookies. Additionally third party cookies are used. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Privacy Policy