EARLY MEDIEVAL SOUTH TYROL

Sin dall’epoca romana, le Alpi funsero da confine naturale (limes), che a partire dal V-VI sec. d.C. fino al regno di Carlo Magno, perse la sua funzione difensiva. I Franchi-Alemanni varcarono il limes da nord-ovest (Val Venosta); i Longobardi (in Italia a partire dal 569 d.C.) si spinsero verso le Alpi da sud (ducato di Trento); i Baiuvari dal nord (Valle dell’Inn e Alta Val d’Isarco) e gli Slavi da est (Val Pusteria). In epoca altomedievale, il territorio alpino ebbe un ruolo chiave in quanto punto di unione strategica tra la penisola italiana ed i territori a nord delle Alpi. I pochi dati storici ed archeologici non permettono però di fare chiarezza sulle dinamiche di interazione tra le popolazioni dette germano-barbariche e quelle romane locali. Infatti, va chiarito in quale misura i cambiamenti culturali fossero dovuti ad un processo naturale di mescolanze ed influenze eterogenee tra le diverse popolazioni o se invece fossero il risultato di un brusco processo di sostituzione. Le dinamiche di popolamento nel territorio altoatesino in epoca altomedievale vanno pertanto chiarite. Fino ad oggi, inoltre, non sono state condotte indagini isotopiche sistematiche ad eccezione dello studio sull'Iceman.

A tale scopo, nel 2014 è stato avviato un progetto di dottorato in collaborazione con l’Ufficio Beni Archeologici della Soprintendenza della Provincia Autonoma di Bolzano e con il Dipartimento di Antropologia dell’Università di Berna (Svizzera). Un campione di circa 150 scheletri provenienti da 9 siti dell’Alto Adige, datati al V-XII sec. d.C., verrà sottoposto a tecniche analitiche finora mai applicate a livello locale e in modo sistematico, quali: analisi antropologiche, paleopatologiche e isotopiche (Carbone, Azoto e Zolfo). Gli obiettivi principali saranno: i) ricostruire il profilo biologico (sesso, età alla morte, misure antropometriche, indicatori muscoloscheletrici) e paleopatologico di tutti gli individui; ii) ricostruire la dieta e mobilità degli individui selezionati e confrontare i dati ottenuti tra le diverse valli.

In South Tyrol, one of the most problematic matter for medieval archeology is the population dynamic in Early Middle Ages. With the Roman Empire decline (476 A.D.), the so-called “barbari” burst into the European scenery. Nevertheless, according to the historical records, since the 4^th century they had actually interacted with Reto-Romans. Thanks to the support of modern disciplines, the idea of a process of cultural heterogeneity and cultural exchange between Romans and Germans, has replaced the old interpretative model that looks at them both as two opposite worlds. Since the 3^rd century A.D., the Alpine area was an important natural defensive shield (limes), that in the 6^th-8^th century was crossed by Franks and Alemannics from the north-west (Venosta Valley); Langobards (568 A.D.) from the south (Trento duchy); Bavarians from the north (Inn Valley, high Isarco Valley) and Slavic populations from the east (Pusteria Valley). Therefore, like the entire Italian peninsula, even South Tyrol became an unstable territory, due to the continued variations of the frontiers. Despite that during the Early Middle Ages, this area had a key role as a strategic junction of populations, ideas and technologies.

The limited records of the historical events related to the “Migration Period” in Trentino Alto-Adige/South Tyrol (Italy), mainly come from the work of Paul the Deacon, Historia Langobardorum (8th century AD) and from few other historical documents collected in the Venetian and Lombardian Italian archives. Not only the historical data but also the archaeological sources offer an unrealistic picture of the medieval events in South Tyrol.

The latest archaeological discoveries (Ufficio 13.2, Beni archeologici Autonomous Province of Bolzano-Bozen) have demonstrated that the territorial and cultural categorizations are not convincing anymore. As an example, in the necropolis at Inn Valley, high Isarco, it is very difficult and often impossible to distinguish the graves that belonged to Reto-Romans from those of Germans, based on grave goods alone. This is due to the strong cultural admixture that forced the local populations to adopt the habits of the reigning kings. So far, it is still unclear in what way and to what extent the German groups interacted with Romans or if the historical-cultural changes were due to admixture or rather replacement events.

In 2014, we started a PhD project in affiliation with the Ufficio 13.2, Beni archeologici Autonomous Province of Bolzano (Italy), the University of Tübingen (Germany) and the Institute of Forensic Medicine of Bern University (Switzerland). This pilot study will insight for the first time the Early Medieval population dynamic in this region, through an interdisciplinary approach.

The aims are to:

i) reconstruct the biological (demography) and the paleopathological profiles of all the skeletal human remains (physical anthropology, paleopathology, ergonomy); 

ii) insight the diet, the subsistence strategies, the environmental adaptations, and socio-economic differences among individuals and/or groups in the valleys during that time (δ¹³C, δ¹⁵N); 

iii) in-depth the events of human mobility in this territory according to spatial (valleys, sites) and chronological parameters  (δ³⁴S).Therefore, morphological and paleopathological investigation, as well as stable isotope (δ13C, δ15N, δ34S) analyses, will be performed on approximately 150 skeletal human remains found in 9 archaeological sites (Fig.1) dated to the Early Middle Age (Tab.1).

Fig.1 Map of South Tyrol, Italy showing the medieval archaeological sites and valleys/basin considered in this study.

Tab.1 Valleys/basin, sites and chronologies selected by the Head of the Ufficio 13.2, Beni archeologici Autonomous Province of Bolzano-Bozen. * unpublished data Province of Bolzano ** EURAC research.  

The skeletal human remains were discovered during archaeological excavations carried out in Alto Adige (Tab.1) by the Ufficio 13.2, Beni archeologici Autonomous Province of Bolzano-Bozen and stored in Frangarto-Frangart (BZ).

As a preliminary stage of the study, it will be necessary to: A) clean the bones with water or brushes, as some of the bones are entirely wrapped with bandages glued to the outer surface. Often the bones are also are covered by a layer of mold. B) Move the skeletal materials from the storehouse of the Ufficio 13.2, Beni archeologici Autonomous Province of Bolzano-Bozen to the laboratory of Anthropology of our Institute.

The analyses of the human bones will include different scientific approaches and methods, such as:

1. Morphology-anthropology:

• Bones and teeth preservation (P) – representation (R): P: 1 poor, 2 intermediate, 3 good; R: levels <25 % poor, 50 -75 % partial, >75 % complete,
• determination of the sex, estimation of the age at death,
• measurements: cranium (Martin & Saller: M1-5-8-9-10-12-17-20-23-24-25-45-47-51-52-54-55-65-66) and postcranium (humerus: M1-4-5-6-7-9-10; Radius: M1-2; Ulna: M1-2; os coxae: M1,12,14, 14.1, 15.1,22,23; Gaillard (1960): SPU, ISMM, SA; Schulter- Ellis et al. (1983): ISMM; femur: 1-2-6-7-8-9-10-21; tibia: 1a- 1b- 3- 8a –9a-10b) to calculate indexes and stature.
• Non-metric traits: cranium (Metopic suture, Lambdoid ossicles, Saggital ossicles, Bregmatic ossicles, Coronal ossicles, Squama parietal ossicles, Parietal notch bone, Inca bone, Apical bone, Double condiloyd facets); upper limbs (scapula- bipartite acromion, humerus- septal aperture); coxae (Pre-auricular sulcus) and lower limbs (femur- Riding facets; tibia- Lateral and Medial squatting).

2. Paleopathology and Entheses:

• Detection of pathological evidences, location and different degrees of expression on the bones surfaces.
• Oral diseases (dental carious lesions, dental calculus, periodontitis, abscesses and linear enamel hypoplasia),
• Developmental-Metabolic (porotic hyperostosis, cribra orbitalia, cranii, palatine, femuri; scurvy; rickets; osteomalacia; enamel hypoplasia),
• Degenerative joint disease (DJD), OA, Schmorl’s nodules,
• Inflammatory disease (Osteomyelitis) and nonspecific (Periostitis)
• Congenital,
• Neoplastic,
• Trauma.
• Entheseal changes on shoulders, upper limbs, coxae and lower limbs, will be analysed according to Villotte (2006, 2010).
• Activity markers indicating horseback riding syndrome.

3. Stable Isotopes:

• Diet: Carbon (δ¹³C), Nitrogen (δ¹⁵N).
• Mobility: Sulphur (δ³⁴S).
• Analyses of animal bones found in the same sites of the human remains, for the human-faunal trophic level
•  All the geochemical and paleobiological results will be published in international journals (Additional details in the Activities section). The final work will be discussed in a cumulative PhD thesis.